Like thousands of websites across the internet, I’m blacking my site out to protest SOPA & PIPA. Because the tools used to black out my website may work differently in different jurisdictions or browsers, I wanted to write a post about why I’m doing this.
All morning long, I’ve been reading posts by creators that I respect and I honestly think that they can say it more eloquently than I can in the short time I have to write this morning, so I’m going to share some of their thoughts:
You done got swindled, sons and daughters of the creative age.
SOPA and PIPA are not about piracy.
They are about control.
See, the Internet is this unruly pubic tangle of possibility. It is raw potential given form and it puts a great deal of power in the hands of the individual (are you listening, creative-types?). Power in the hands of individuals can, in some cases, wrest power from the hands of corporations. And corporations don’t like that, so they go to the government and they pour giant buckets of money into the government’s slavering maw and lobby for legislation and the result is, in this case, SOPA, PIPA, and any other naughty anti-pirate hydra-heads that pop up.
Writers and creatives — again, as individuals — have a lot of opportunity in the Internet Age, in part due to the innovation and distribution the Internet offers, in part due to the social media that connects us all. Harming these by harming the Internet then harms free expression. And that’s no good.
Just to be clear, in case you don’t realize what it means to give corporations power over censorship and the subject of artistic originality, please cast an eye no further to the MPAA, whose arbitrary and often insane ratings of films put out by the film industry help stifle creativity and the craft and art of filmmaking. You really want that kind of control over sites like YouTube, Twitter, Tumblr, Google, Wikipedia?
No, you do not.
SOPA and PIPA hit the issue with a hammer when what’s called for is a scalpel.
— Chuck Wendig
I believe every owner of copyrights — everyone who creates art — has these same moral and legal rights, and should have the same ability to address violations. Creators should be able to present their creations on their terms, not anyone else’s.
SOPA/PIPA aren’t the way to do this. These proposed laws are poorly constructed, overly broad and frankly thoughtless, the equivalent of dealing with burglars in someone’s home by carpetbombing every house on the street. You might stop the burglar, but the collateral damage makes it a hollow victory. The collateral damage here would be the hamstringing of the Internet, and trampling rights of speech and expression. That these proposed laws have been debated by a number of US Representatives and Senators who seemed proud of their ignorance of how the Internet works (and at least initially didn’t want to hear from technical experts) made it that much worse.
— John Scalzi
I am not American, nor do I live in America. But the internet is an interdependent creature, and unilateral SOPA or PIPA actions will affect the entire animal. One country, even a country I love and admire, should not wield that power, especially in service of a cause both confused and mendacious.
— Warren Ellis
If you don’t see the blackout page on my website, you can use the easy tools at this website to contact your legislators to do your part to stop SOPA & PIPA: http://americancensorship.org/
johnnymurdoc.com | Follow RSS | Find Johnny Murdoc on: Facebook | Twitter